About WRc | Portfolio Programme | Help | Contact Us  
Portfolio Logo WRc
Home New Ideas New On Site New Starts Proposed
Your List

Asset Maintenance
Asset Management
Business Planning
Business Processes
Carbon Footprint
Carbon Management
Catchment Management
Climate Change
Customer Service
Data & Information
Data Management
Demand Management
Distribution Management
Drinking Water Quality
Emergency Planning
Energy Efficiency
Environmental Management
Environmental Policy & Legislation
Investment Planning
Leak Detection
Metering & Charging
Odour Management
Operating Costs
Pipeline Materials
Real Time Control
Receiving Water Quality
Resource Management
Risk Assessment
Risk Management
Spatial Information
Strategic Planning
Supply Demand Management
Technology Development
Underground Assets
Waste & Resource Management
Waste Management
Wastewater Treatment
Water & Wastewater
Water Distribution
Water Quality
Water Resources
Water Treatment
Water Treatment Waste
Water Use

Printer Friendly VersionSelected Information - Completed Research

CP326  Alternative Filtration Media Water Treatment
Project Appreciation and Objectives

Sand is used universally as a filtration medium in drinking water treatment. Many alternatives are available that have approval for use in drinking water filtration. These include sustainable products (e.g. recycled glass), also quarried and "engineered" materials (e.g. expanded clays). Various claims are made as to the benefits of specific products relative to sand, in order to justify a greater initial material cost. For deep bed filtration, the claims include: greater particle removal efficiency; more effective cleaning of bed, leading to smaller backwash water requirements; longer operating life. Some products could also be used for slow sand filtration. There is a need to understand the true relative benefits of the various commercial products for specific water treatment applications.

This project undertook an independent review of the availability, specification, whole life cost and performance of alternative filtration media.

Benefits to Clients

  • Identification of filtration media with superior performance and lower whole life costs than conventional media.
  • Identification of sustainable filtration products as part of a wider environmental policy.

Work Programme

Phase 1

  1. The environmental and/or other claimed benefits of alternative filtration media, from sustainable, quarried and "engineered" sources, were identified.
  2. Potential applications and expected advantages were established. Gaps in knowledge requiring further investigation were identified.

Phase 2

  1. Laboratory testing to verify specifications (e.g. size distribution, voidage, density, attrition rate) and specific aspects of performance (e.g. surface activity and adsorption properties).
  2. Selected media were tested at pilot scale. Performance relative to sand were assessed from, e.g.: ripening time, solids capacity; particle removal efficiency; adsorption; backwash requirements for effective cleaning. Successful materials were recommended for evaluation at full scale possibly as a final phase to project.

Technical support was provided by Caroline Fitzpatrick, Head of Env. Eng. Group at UCL.

Project Output

Phase 1

  • A report detailing the options for alternative media, their availability, approximate cost, claimed performance as well as gaps in knowledge.

Phase 2

  • A comprehensive report on the detailed results of laboratory and pilot scale testing of media identified during Phase 1. Alternatives that have clear advantages over conventional materials were recommended for full scale evaluation.
  • A workshop to review the benefits of alternative media.

Related WRc Work

  • Extensive testing of filtration sand and support gravel for Garside Sands Ltd., using upgraded plant facility , Major utility, 2006
  • Testing of alternative media eg ferric hydroxide adsorbent and pumice, Media suppliers, 2001-2004
  • Media testing during process audits, numerous utility clients, 1990 - present
WRc's Portfolio Programme
Summary of the £1.5 million per annum research programme

More details...

About WRc | Portfolio Programme | Hot Topics | Help | Contact Us